I can’t begin to count how many times I’ve needed breadcrumbs for a recipe, only to go to the pantry to discover I’d run out. I use them so often—for everything from cutlets to fish and pasta toppings—that I can hardly keep up. The solution (in addition to maintaining a better weekly shopping list) is to keep myself in good supply by making my own. It’s not only incredibly easy, it’s also a great way to make use of leftover bread that’s definitely its prime, allowing you to stock up on breadcrumbs while minimizing food waste. You can also make breadcrumbs from fresh bread in a pinch by drying it in a low oven, a handy trick for when you’re out of both store-bought breadcrumbs and stale old bread.

Homemade breadcrumbs can be made from a variety of bread types, such as sourdough, white bread, and rye, and can come from crusty rustic loaves or basic sandwich bread. There will be differences in flavor and texture, depending on what kind of bread you use, but in all but the most extreme cases, the breadcrumbs can be used interchangeably. The one thing to try to avoid are loaves of bread studded with seeds, nuts, dried fruit, and other add-ins, which can gunk up the batch and throw off the recipe results.

Breadcrumbs are made by pulsing stale or oven-dried bread in a food processor until the bread breaks down into small crumbs. The exact size of the crumbs depends on personal preference and at times specific recipe needs, though it’s generally better to err on the side of larger crumbs, since they can always be crushed or processed more if a finer grind is needed. Be careful not to overprocess the bread, though, or you’ll be left with an overly fine powder.

Vicky Wasik

It’s also generally better to leave the breadcrumbs unsalted and unseasoned for storage. That will give you the most versatility for later use—you can toast and season them later if, say, you want to use them as a garnish for pasta, or leave them uneaten to use as a coating for cutlets, since they’ll brown during the frying process.

As for whether to remove the crusts or not, that’s harder to say. Crusts can often be left on, although more rustic loaves with a darker and thicker crust will produce breadcrumbs with a noticeable proportion of deeply browned bits. Those crusty breadcrumbs may be delicious when used as a garnish for pasta but can over-brown during deep-frying. The most versatile breadcrumbs are arguably free of a very dark crust, but again, it ultimately depends on what you’re likely to do with them.

Seasoned Breadcrumbs: Ideas for Adding Flavor

Whether homemade or store-bought, breadcrumbs are open to a wide range of flavoring and seasoning possibilities. Keep in mind that adding fresh seasonings to your breadcrumbs will shorten their lifespan, so you can always keep a batch of plain breadcrumbs on hand and add the fresh ingredients on a recipe-by-recipe basis.

Vicky Wasik

Some of our favorite seasoning options include:

  • salt: The most basic seasoning, salt improves breadcrumbs just as it improves any food, making flavors pop.
  • Fresh or dried herbs: Dried herbs are best limited to woodsy herbs like oregano, sage, rosemary, and thyme, which retain their flavor even when dried. If using fresh herbs, you can use any of those same woodsy herbs as well as more delicate fresh ones like finely minced parsley, chives, and tarragon.
  • Spices: Freshly ground black pepper is the most obvious choice here (so obvious some might have listed it alongside salt above), but it’s not the only one. Garlic and onion powder, ground coriander, fennel, or cumin seeds, and flavored powerhouses like smoked paprika are just some examples of spices that would be welcome in many breadcrumb mixtures.
  • citrus zest: The zest of lemon and orange in particular can work wonders in a breadcrumb mixture. We’ve used lemon zest before making “gremolata” breadcrumbs along with minced fresh parsley and garlic.
  • Fresh garlic and other alliums: Building on the gremolata breadcrumbs idea just mentioned, fresh minced garlic, shallots, or scallions can add depth and dimension. Minced chives could also be listed here, if you don’t want to think of them as herbs.
  • Oils: If you’re planning on toasting your breadcrumbs before using them as a garnish, or if you’re air-frying or oven-roasting a food with a breadcrumb exterior, such as in these avocado fries, moistening the breadcrumbs with oil will improve how evenly the breadcrumbs toast while avoiding an overly dry texture. Just add the oil with care, since a little bit goes a long way.
  • Graded Cheeses: Finely grated Parmigiano-Reggiano, Pecorino Romano, and other aged cheeses are another excellent addition to a breadcrumb mixture.